From here, reports can be downloaded about the project and the findings at the dig, which makes it very easy to deduce how reliable the article is. Although the BBC News article does not seem to give any misinformation (the SHARP website gives details about the clay object being a potential bread oven), it does seem to miss out a lot of information about the site. For example, BBC News does not tell us about the variety of different areas at the site, of which Chalk Pit is the location of the clay bread oven (Faulkner, 2009).Additionally, BBC news does not give information about how the clay bread oven was aged. The SHARP website tells us that it was evaluated by experts as well as being sent off for further dating in a laboratory. Without this information, it is difficult to know whether the 1300 year figure given is accurate, and whether there could be an error in dating. Additionally, the SHARP website gives the date as being 1300-1400 years old, meaning that readers of the BBC article could be misinformed about the specificity of the date given.One excellent part of the BBC News article is that it explores the thought process behind making the decision that the object was a bread oven. For example, it details that it was initially thought to be “Roman” but a decision was made about the age by using a “piece of middle Saxon pottery” (BBC News, 2013). Additionally, it explains the colouration of the object by stating how the heat of a bread oven would make the white local clay turn to red. Although this is all detailed on the dig website, it is interesting to see that this information is carried over to the general public, and the fact that the information matches up between the two stories suggests that the BBC News article is reliable.Having examined the information about the site at Sedgeford, there are a number of different methods that I think would benefit the site. Firstly, a period of fieldwalking may be useful to identify different features and find small artefacts which may aid the investigation. This method is good for sites spread over a large area, such as Sedgeford, and may help the volunteers define the edges of the potential Anglo Saxon settlement which was suggested by the BBC News article (Roskams, 2001). Additionally, fieldwalking may bring up new surprises about the site.The website for the dig also mentions that
BBC News. (2013, July 24). “Rare bread oven” found in dig. BBC. Retrieved from http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-norfolk-23409930
Faulkner, N. (2009). The Sedgeford Crisis. Public Archaeology, 8(1), 51–61. doi:10.1179/175355309X402754
Renfrew, C., & Bahn, P. G. (2012). Archaeology: Theories, Methods and Practice. Thames & Hudson, Limited.
Roskams, S. (2001). Excavation. Cambridge University Press.
SHARP. (2013). Sharp. Retrieved October 26, 2013, from http://www.sharp.org.uk/research-areas/chalk-pit-field-north.html
Please type your essay title, choose your document type, enter your email and we send you essay samples